Entertainment Industry Will Sue IrelandAdded: Monday, January 16th, 2012
Category: Recent Headlines Involving File Sharing > Current Events
Tags:ET, p2p, Torrent, Piracy, Peer To Peer, Network, Hackers, Internet, BitTorrent, Google, utorrent, bitcomet, extratorrent, 2010, www.extrattorrent.com
Ireland might become the first country to be brought down by the music industry for failing to do what it is told regarding to file-sharing. According to the reports, entertainment industry is currently going to sue the cash-strapped Irish government for failing to bring in a copyright legislation that blocks sites.
The entertainment industry wants websites it mentions to be blocked without having to go to trial. So, if the Ireland doesn’t do what it is told, it will be claimed a pirate and must be brought down. It seems that the background to this case is hidden in the October 2010 judgment in EMI vs UPC case, where the judge decided that Irish legislation didn’t permit to make an order against an Internet service provider demanding blocking of online services.
The entertainment industry replied that considering the fact that the country hadn’t enacted the proper legislation, it can be held liable for all the file-sharing committed in Ireland. This is going to be worth several trillion to the industry, with the attorneys adding lots of zeros, which means that the Irish government can become the first nation state to be sued into insolvency.
Actually, Ireland has already said that they will develop some “statutory” tool to let the blocking of sites be implemented in accordance to European legislation in the next week. However, it doesn’t look like the industry wants exactly the ability to block a site. Recently, the Irish Data Protection Commissioner has already decided against Eircom's “three-strikes” regime, and if any “statutory” tool allows for blocking online services, it won’t allow a SOPA legislation where the music industry orders a broadband provider to take offline a website without any evidence.
It seems that the music industry is going to use the European law principle, first used in Italy, where the damages are now possible against the government for failure to implement an EU directive. However, it might appear tricky to get a conviction: the music industry would have to prove that filtering online services prevents piracy and demonstrate that Ireland didn't bring in a legislation in question fast enough.
Thus far, the experts believe that in the unlikely event that the industry wins with the damages being on a common file-sharing level and the country remaining as broke as it is, the industry would be in a very interesting situation of owning a country.
January 16th,2012Posted by:
Monday, January 16th, 2012
|posted by (2012-01-16 12:26:34)|
|let them sue Ireland it's only worth 10 euros.|
|posted by (2012-01-16 12:50:03)|
|so much for the luck of the Irish?|
|Yeah, take on one of the longest running terrorist organisations (in recent times) in Europe, see how long it is before you get a letter bomb...|
For once, I'd actually support the IRA
|posted by (2012-01-16 15:59:04)|
|thiochigh ar la|
|posted by (2012-01-17 04:12:10)|
|You cant sue a country,you cant win a lawsuit against the tax payers of another nation,you cant even sue government officials from another country,diplomatic immunity = End of story|
|Ridiculous sounds like ireland is being blackmailed by the corporate goverments who think they are above us.Just imagine if no-one paid to see a artist they would go down fast,people power is bigger than these pricks...|
|posted by (2012-01-17 22:51:20)|
|@chasnjas yes you can sue Ireland, you will be sueing the government who represent the state,namely Ireland, and it wouldnt matter a shit i dont think the IMF would be too pleased about bailing us out again for a bunch of tin whistle blowing musicians who cant even sell there own music in the shops legally. Even U2 dont pay taxes in this country any more. And maybe these crying useless musicians might do a better job running the coutry than the monkeys we have|
|posted by (2012-01-18 06:35:16)|
|I've been trying to sue Ireland for years for the crime of creating and harbouring tone deaf talentless noise polluters but my attempts to get the suspects extradited is proving difficult as the country's grans have formed a defensive ring around them. Any assistance with the prosecution of Westlife and Boyzone for crimes against music and the supply of class A pap would be appreciated.|
|number 10 you forgot bewitched aswell|
|posted by (2012-01-18 22:35:09)|
|OK, Let me be the first to apologise for inflicting the world with westlife, boyzone and most of all bewitched, its all that little cunt louis walshes fault, we are so so sorry.|
|there should be a class action suit against the entertainment industry for tricking people into buying inferior products all the time without knowing just how bad it is until after they wasted their money.|
switzerland has it right, the numbers are exagerated, they are making more money than they admit and they did the same thing about cassette recorders, and vcrs, scanners, photocopiers, etc.
thats like kodak trying to stop digital photos because they aren't buying their film.
there is a reason dinosaurs are extinct.
Most Popular Stories